“We want to continue pioneering by embracing the newest and best standard technologies”
SIDN Tech sets the tone in the international domain name industry with new ICT strategy
SIDN Tech sets the tone in the international domain name industry with new ICT strategy
--- For detailed explanatory and background information linked to this article, see our update of 2 April. We regret that our communications regarding the proposal to migrate the registration system for .nl domain names to the AWS platform weren't as clear as they should have been, and therefore caused considerable debate. We are now in continuous dialogue with the Dutch internet community. We've also made an undertaking that no irreversible steps will be taken until, amongst other things, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy has completed its quick scan of possible Dutch and European alternatives to AWS. Meanwhile, we remain as committed as ever to working in various ways to support a decentralised internet and the digital autonomy of our community. ---
The technical infrastructure that supports the registration of .nl domain names will undergo fundamental change over the next 2 years. The aim is to simplify our technical management and increase the scope for developing new services. SIDN's new CTO Loek Bakker explains the background.
"For many years, SIDN has been using a bespoke domain registration system (DRS) developed in house and known as DRS5. It still works very well, but it's now a little behind the times. Consequently, away from the public gaze, our engineers are having to devote quite a lot of time to the management and maintenance of DRS5. We're not alone, though: registries in other countries face similar problems. So we've decided to team up with CIRA, the organisation that runs Canada's .ca internet domain. We going to become co-owners of CIRA's powerful domain registration platform, Fury. Fury is a popular system that the registries in countries such as Ireland and New Zealand already rely on. It makes use of the latest technologies, including RDAP: a protocol that enables the structured lookup of information about domain name registrants. From 2025, all generic top-level domains such as .com will have to support RDAP. We want to make Fury even more accessible, though. So we'll be working with our Canadian colleagues over the next 2 years to migrate the platform to the public cloud. It'll be a joint development effort, with the added benefit that, once Fury's in the cloud, we'll be able to offer 'DRS as a service' to other registries. A lot of interest in the concept has already been expressed within the industry. People like the idea, because domain registration systems aren't available from big suppliers like Microsoft and Oracle. There simply isn't enough demand to make DRS development attractive to players like that. So, in partnership with CIRA, we intend to step into that space."
CIRA and SIDN agree on partnership to build new registry platform"We're a relatively small organisation. So we have to constantly ask ourselves, what knowledge should we retain in house, within the team, because of its high added value? And what's the market better at than we are? We've opted to have a domain registration system of our own, but to share the development and maintenance costs with CIRA."
Loek Bakker joined SIDN as CTO on 1 September 2023. He had previously headed up the Information Management Office at TenneT and been Head of Information Management at Alliander. Other previous roles include an associate directorship at research agency Gartner. At consultancy firm Capgemini, he advised on organisational matters at the interface between business and ICT. He graduated in 1999 from Erasmus University, Rotterdam, where he read Public Administration and researched the impact of new internet technologies on the business world.
"Registries all around the world are coming to the conclusion that there's little added value in operating their own infrastructures. Hardware and energy prices are going up all the time, and it's increasingly difficult to recruit the people you need to operate the kind of infrastructure a registry needs. Also, you're unnecessarily vulnerable as an organisation if the continuity of your operations depend on the expertise of just a handful of individuals. Another significant factor is that internet domains everywhere are no longer growing the way they were. However, the costs are increasing, driven up by things such as the need to invest more in cybersecurity. To some extent, a registry can cover its expanding cost base by increasing prices. But we want to continue pioneering by embracing the newest and best standard technologies. We've therefore been looking around for creative ways to reinforce our core activities, while also making it even easier to bring new services to market. At the moment, our systems are housed in 2 data centres. Managing those systems is very time-consuming. Yet operating our own Linux servers doesn't have any real advantage internationally or in terms of the service we provide to our customers. Over the next 2 years, therefore, we'll be migrating part of our ICT environment, including Fury, to Amazon Web Services (AWS). The process should be complete by early 2026. My personal belief is that the whole sector will move to the cloud in the coming 5 to 8 years. So the strategy we've adopted will put us ahead of the curve."
"Of course, the big question is, why are you moving your essential services to the public cloud, when it's so important to safeguard Europe's digital autonomy? The short answer to that question is that there isn't yet a mature European alternative. As soon as one becomes available, we'll be looking to switch. It's therefore vital that we have an exit strategy. In essence, what that strategy consists of is following 'vendor-agnostic architectural principles' when migrating to the cloud. We'll be using open standards wherever we can, and implementing as few AWS-specific functions as possible. Each step along the way will be evaluated. We're promising to share our knowledge with our stakeholders, even about things that, in hindsight, we think we should have done differently. For example, we're going to compile a manual as we go, documenting all the dos and don'ts of vendor-agnostic cloud engineering that we've identified. SIDN Labs' Director Cristian Hesselman and I will soon be writing a blog, describing our plans in more detail."
"Migration to the public cloud will allow us to bring in new services more quickly, more easily and more cheaply. Take the popular SIDN BrandGuard service, which enables organisations to protect their domain names against phishing and reputation damage. At the moment, SIDN BrandGuard is tailored to the corporate segment. However, once we've migrated to AWS, it'll be quite straightforward to scale up the service and offer it to the SME market. We're planning to modernise everything, while also optimising the reliability of our established services for the .nl internet domain. That'll mean investing in cybersecurity as well, to counter the increased global threat level created by political unrest."
We're going to further increase the availability of our anycast platform in order to make our DNS structure even more resistant to cyber-attacks and other external threats. Anycast routing technology lets you fall back on backup capacity immediately whenever the need arises. Tasks are automatically distributed optimally across a network of available servers. The intention is also to offer our anycast platform as a service to other registries, so they too can increase the availability of their domains. The platform is already being used for the .amsterdam domain and for .cw and .aw – the country-code domains of Curaçao and Aruba. In the future, it may be used for other top-level domains as well. Another enhancement we've got planned is raising our information security level. We already comply with ISO 27001:2013, and the aim is to achieve ISO 27001:2022 compliance. Meanwhile, with the longer-term security of our DNS structure in mind, SIDN Labs is researching quantum-secure cryptographic algorithms."
SIDN will become co-owner of Fury, the domain registration system (DRS) developed by CIRA, the registry for Canada's internet domain. Over the next 2 years, SIDN will also migrate part of its ICT environment, including Fury but excluding the DNS systems, to the public cloud. The move will enable SIDN to reduce its operating costs. It will also open the way for the development of new, cloud-based services – particularly services close to the core processes with which SIDN has been a pioneer for more than 25 years: domain registration and secure operation of the DNS infrastructure of the .nl domain.
"We're going to further streamline and standardise all our processes. And we'll be restructuring our ICT organisation accordingly. Within our technical division – known as SIDN Tech since 1 January – we've formed 3 teams reflecting our 3 primary ambition realms: Software Engineering, Cloud Engineering and ICT & Security Operations. We also want to reinforce the link between SIDN Tech and our research department SIDN Labs. That will enable the 2 units to make optimal use of one another's experience, knowledge and contacts."
"SIDN Tech's engineers will be given extensive training opportunities, so they can learn about the newest and best technologies. Also, because we'll be working in smaller teams of 10 to 15 people, we'll be able to pay even more attention to each individual's professional development. There's a bit of nervous excitement around the place, with people wondering what the changes might mean for them. But the transition has implications for SIDN as a whole, not just for SIDN Tech. We're expanding as well: we're already talking to applicants for 3 new posts. And we're always keen to hear from talented people who want to deepen their knowledge of the internet's core processes. I myself read Public Administration at university, graduating in 1999. But I was always very interested in the internet: my thesis was about the impact of new internet technologies on the business world. The people at SIDN love the internet and really buy into our main mission of safeguarding the continuity of the Dutch internet domain. And I'm not just talking about the engineers at SIDN Tech and SIDN Labs: everyone in our business, support and communications departments feels the same. It's not by chance that they work here. Since starting at SIDN on 1 September, I've found that everyone I meet is very much aware of the huge importance of the internet for the way organisations operate, and for society as a whole."
"Our ambition is to make the Fury platform available in an AWS test environment by the end of 2024. Then, early next year, we'll start testing it with our customers. By the end of 2025, we should have migrated all our systems – except for the DNS systems – from our own data centres to AWS, and shut down our own data centres. In January 2026, we'll switch off DRS5, and we want to go live with Fury. At the same time, we'll start offering DRS as a service to the international market. Over the next 2 years, we'll be reinforcing our core services: DNS and DRS. We're going to make them even more resilient than they already are, while also expanding and improving our services. Migration to the cloud can only help us achieve those goals."
We can assure everyone that the difficult decision to migrate our systems to AWS was not taken lightly or in haste. It is important to understand that it is only our registration system that is being migrated, not our core resolving service or the associated DNS infrastructure. Furthermore, we are continuing to use data centres in Europe, where our data will remain properly secured. With the help of external consultants, we have thoroughly evaluated all possible alternatives. However, we have been obliged to conclude that, regrettably, no suitable alternative currently exists. Although we seek to contribute to the strategic digital autonomy of the Netherlands and Europe in numerous ways, the need to assure the permanent availability of .nl and the protection of our data was decisive in this instance. That is, after all, our primary responsibility as a registry. We are nevertheless committed to ensuring that our registration system is not dependent on any particular cloud service provider, and we will be using generic, open-source technology, so that, as soon as it becomes responsible to migrate the system to a Dutch or European cloud service provider, we are able to do so relatively easily.