New domain name extensions delayed by demands for action on abuse
Lively debate at ICANN 71
Lively debate at ICANN 71
The 71st ICANN Meeting took place this month. Having been chosen before the pandemic, The Hague was the nominal venue, but the meeting was actually held online. One topic that gave rise to fierce debate was the proposed new top-level domain (nTLD) application window. The US and European governments want more done to prevent DNS abuse before they give their backing to the proposal. However, would-be applicants, such as Uber and eBay, believe that their market access is being blocked because of a problem that's got nothing to do with new TLDs.
The ICANN Board was extremely direct. In the period ahead, preparations for the application window will continue with an operational design phase. Once the operational design is ready, the Board will make a decision.
The idea of a new window lacks support from some sections of the ICANN community, however. Represented by the Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC), governments have proved particularly reluctant to back the idea. They want to see serious progress on DNS abuse before ICANN pushes ahead with the nTLD window. That stance cuts little ice with many other representatives, who argue that the problem of DNS abuse mainly affects existing generic domain name extensions, such as .com and .info.
The GAC asked the GNSO, the body that represents generic domain name extensions, to do more about domain abuse. The GNSO has not yet responded, however, partly because many of its members seems to regard the request as a diversionary tactic.
Because the US and European governments are the main advocates of delay, and because most new TLD applicants are based in the US and Europe, it looks unlikely that there will be a breakthrough any time soon. Further delay is therefore in prospect. The various ICANN 71 sessions were recorded and are available to watch using this link.
Are you interested in your own top-level domain and would you like to know more about what we can do for you? Check out our website or contact our product manager Pim Pastoors on +31 6 570 454 07 or pim.pasoors@sidn.nl.