Filterbubbel.nl promotes discussion and reduces 'us-and-them' thinking in schools

SIDN Fund supports nationwide rollout of the Filter Bubble project

Illustration of a hand holding a smartphone on which images are swiped away.

Unnuanced 'us-and-them' thinking is on the rise in Dutch schools. What's more, the teaching materials used in practical and vocational secondary education are poorly aligned with young people's lived experience, and are often too language-centred for the target audience. In response, a platform called Filterbubbel.nl has been created. It's aimed at first and second-year vocational secondary students and focuses on digital skills such as critical thinking. The material on the platform is designed to tie in with the way young people experience the world and covers topics such as filter bubbles, disinformation and algorithms. "The lessons have been successfully tested at schools in Utrecht, and it's now time for a nationwide rollout," says media education advisor Ilse Meursinge, the creative mind behind the initiative.

Platform for vocational secondary students

Ilse Meursinge, media education advisor and the creative brain behind Filterbubble.nl
Ilse Meursinge, media education advisor

"Filterbubbel.nl provides materials for low-threshold, creative and interactive lessons designed to get young people thinking about topics, so as to address 'us-and-them' thinking in schools," Ilse explains. "The materials look at things such as forming your own opinions, algorithms, filter bubbles, disinformation, the future of social media, the news that appears in your feed, conspiracy theories and online quackery. Everything has been developed in consultation with young people, teachers and youth workers. As a result, the lessons are visual, practical and interactive. Each of them involves individual online assignments, a group assignment and a class-based sum-up. First, students watch an animation in class. Then each student explores the topic individually online. After that, the youngsters get together in groups to do a 'bubble-breaker' assignment. That involves a series of short tasks designed to make them aware of their own thought patterns and the differences and similarities between their individual (online) filter bubbles."

Positive experiences and increased awareness

Logo of Filterbubbel.nl

Filterbubbel.nl received an enthusiastic response from a group of schools in the Dutch city of Utrecht invited to test the platform. "We had a lot of positive feedback," confirms Ilse. "It was particularly clear that students thought the material was quite different from the mainstream. The lessons address issues that are part of young people's everyday lives, even if they don't always realise it. Another thing the feedback showed was that the lessons have a real effect on awareness. Students get to see why certain content appears in their feeds, and that people with different backgrounds and experiences can see things differently. So they get a glimpse of one another's online worlds and learn to explain why they make particular choices and what they're influenced by."

Nationwide rollout

"Having received positive feedback from users, it was time to move on to the next phase: making the platform more widely available so that more students and teachers around the country can benefit," Ilse continues. "Various technical improvements were made to enable that. For example, a visitor can now register their school for access to the online environment and a free introductory lesson. If they like that and pay for wider access, they get to explore an online environment with all the supporting material. We're currently doing a trial mini-launch, as a dry run for the full launch in September."

Support from SIDN Fund

Mieke van Heesewijk, Programme Manager at SIDN Fund

"The support of SIDN Fund has been invaluable," says Ilse. "The Fund's financial assistance has enabled us to create the platform and now to organise the nationwide rollout. But they have been really helpful in other ways as well. Through the Fund, we've built up contacts with the organisers of other projects and other organisations with similar aims. That's led to the exchange of a lot of ideas. The confidence that SIDN Fund showed in us has given us the opportunity to scale up this initiative and make it something truly worthwhile."

Explaining the background to the Fund's involvement, Project Manager Mieke van Heesewijk says, "It's wonderful to see Filterbubbel.nl being rolled out to the whole country, helping to tackle the rise of 'us-and-them' thinking in schools. The platform's creative, interactive lessons will improve vocational secondary students' understanding of how online processes work and how to look outside their own filter bubbles. So the project is contributing to a more nuanced, cohesive society."

Still more ideas

According to Ilse, Filter Bubble's nationwide rollout doesn't mean that the project will soon be complete. "We've got lots more ideas," she says "For example, we've started work on supporting services for schools. We noticed that the schools using the platform were also interested in things such as organising parents' evenings, teacher training and study mornings linked to particular topics. We've also had enquiries from libraries wanting to get hold of the support materials. And we're big believers in bespoke products tailored to particular practical goals. So we're working with our network contacts to develop concepts using that model."